...about non-profit organisations.
Last March I donated $30 to a non-profit charity group. I won't say which one because in the end, I think they do good work. They take homeless and runaway kids off the streets, give them a place to sleep, shower, get clothes, and try to figure out what to do next. From what I understand, there are so many kids who need a place to go, and I was happy to give them some money (it was in lieu of a present for my brother's birthday). The group was recommended to me by a friend.
And as I rather like teenagers, I thought this was ideal. I sent them a donation, they sent my bro a card stating as much, and that was that.
Two weeks later, the letters started coming. First it was, "Hi, it's Joe here, and I run (organisation). Late last night, a young girl named 'Jane' came to us, hungry, desperate, and terrified of returning to her house where her step-father would do 'all kinds of bad things' to her. We were busting at the seams, but I found a place to give this poor young child a good night's rest.
"Without your help, this can't continue...won't you please fill in the enclosed card and donate just $40??..." etc etc.
And I thought, sure, no problem. This is a cause I believe in.
Since then, I have gotten at least two letters a week, each more lurid in description of the abuse some of these kids suffer (some sound like court testimonies). The details are harrowing, but I haven't donated since because I don't like to be guilted into anything. And we're saving for a house. I'm sorry, but we have our own problems, and of late I've become very Adjust Your Mask Before Attempting to Help Others in my thinking.
Then the packages arrived. I got pads of paper, pewter angel keychains, a large blanket, a tote bag, address labels...something comes at least three times a month, and that's not including the bi-weekly mailings pleading for money. It's like a grim Christmas.
This last week I got stamps. Yep, honest-to-goodness stamps saying, "These are real. Please fill in the donation card and send it back, on us. That's how serious we are about you donating." I put the stamps in the drawer and chucked the rest of it.
Because I don't understand how a group that claims to run strictly on charity can keep sending me stuff like this. The mailings I can understand, but even paper and toner cost money. And all the other stuff?? I'm thinking next I'll be getting a mug in the mail saying, "Courtesy of (group). While you're drinking your warm beverage, think of how many kids are on the street FREEZING right now because of you and your miserly ways."
So that's my question. How can they keep doing this, sending all this stuff? Wouldn't the money be better spent in actually putting toward the kids? Never have I seen such a hard sell with a charity group that claims to need money yet spends it so freely.
The obvious answer is, of course, to send them a note saying, Lookit, quit bugging me. I donated once or twice, but you've really turned me off now. I recognise you do good work, but man, your PR is really sending a conflicting message.
Can you do that and not go to hell??
I think you can. Realistically, some of the operating budget of most charities is earmarked for fund-raising. Even my little A&R group has to spend some cash to make much more.
ReplyDeleteIt does strike me as manipulative to send gifts and things in the hopes of getting donations in return, but in the world of raising money, if you don't appeal, you get ignored. The truth is that once that check is in the mail, most people aren't thinking about giving to that charity ever again.
As a charity, you have to make sure that the people that have been kind in the past remember to be kind again in the future too. It's a double-edged sword: if they leave you alone, there's a good chance you'll leave them alone.
If it makes you feel better, you can look them up online and compare their overhead costs to the amount that goes directly to their mission.
And if you give locally to charities staffed by volunteers that help people right in your line of sight, you're more likely to see all your money go to the people who need it and less to staff salaries and fund-raising efforts.
How you give doesn't matter, only that you do.
I'm with you! I once made the mistake of donating to a hunger organization (a special mission run by our church) by check. My name was sold to hundreds (thousands!?) of other charities, and I have been the recipient of: T-shirts (charity that feeds Native American children); rosaries; religious medals; and prayer cards for stuff like helping African children, contributing to religious orders retirement funds, you name it. I finally decided that I would either throw the items out, or put them in the lost and found basket at our church. It infuriates me. However, I learned my lesson. I now donate "in kind" (i.e., food, clothing etc.) or cash. And I try now to keep my charities local.
ReplyDelete