Friday, February 11, 2011

WTF Friday: Duke Finds Obese People Are To Blame for Rising Health Care Prices

I was thumbing through the most recent issue of the Duke University Alumni magazine as I sat on the john the other day, about the only time I get to read undisturbed and in all truthfulness, my short sessions are all the time I care to devote to Duke's publication because quite frankly, I get fed up with their WE ARE DUKE...WE ARE GENETICALLY SUPERIOR TO ALL LIFE FORMS attitude, when an article caught my eye and made me clench up a bit. Not a good thing, considering where I was sitting.

It was a study (and God knows how Duke University loves itself a study proving just about anything it wants to because they've got the money and the backing) which concluded that obese people in the workplace tend to be less effective at their jobs and cost a company's health insurance more money because of their illnesses and how expensive it is to treat them.

You know, because obese people always have diabetes, high blood pressure, and heart disease on account of all the doughnuts they sit around scarfing, washed down by all the sugar-laden coffees consumed on company time. Apparently after such a gorging, fat people waddle off to their desks where they sit staring blankly at their computers for 20 minutes before they pick up the phone and inform their bosses they're taking the day off because they're too fat to work and don't feel well.

At least, that's the image that Eric Finkelstein, author and propaganda minister of this study would have you believe.

The article in the magazine was a bit abbreviated, so I dug a little deeper to find the specifics. And then I started poking some holes which let in a whole lotta light.

Finkelstein's yard stick for measuring obesity was based on the widely discredited BMI scale which straight away sent up red flags in my head. When a study begins to lose credibility within the first paragraph, that's when I cease to be upset by it and begin to be amused, the same way you watch someone who's so clearly guilty of a crime flounder and protest their innocence even as the bailiff is clapping the handcuffs around their wrists.

Just for tickles and damp panties, I looked up "BMI", and I found something really interesting. Even though it's gained popularity in the last 20 years or so, take a guess as to when the BMI scale was invented.

If you said mid-1800s, you're either very smart or incredibly lucky.

Because that's right. Body Mass Index was invented between 1830 and 1850 by the Belgian polymath Adolphe Quetelet. It's a heuristic method, meaning it's not exact and gains its data by trial-and-error and experiment. Which means it's nowhere near accurate enough to be used as a certified diagnostic tool. For it to be an accepted scientific principle, it would have to be true every time, in every instance, tested reliably with roughly the same result each time in a variety of conditions. And it's not.

Because you're talking about people's body mass composition, the end product as opposed to the cause. Shall I point out that people are heavy for a variety of reasons, or am I preaching to a saturated and dozing choir? For BMI to be a reliable scientific method of determining what makes up a person's body, it would take a LOT more than simply weighing someone, then consulting a chart for a random number for your ranking. By that reckoning, a body builder, who is a solid wall of muscle, would be labeled obese on a BMI chart purely based on weight and height.

Would you tell a guy who could bench press you and your best friend at the same time that he's in the same health risk category as a guy who eats food from buckets, guzzles soda and beer, and gets no exercise is? Or that because of his BMI score, he doesn't qualify for insurance?

(I'll be waiting for what's left of you right over here if you do...)

Why do doctors still use the BMI? Quite bluntly, it's cheap, requires no medical forethought or evaluation or even one of the most accurate diagnostic tools in a doctor's arsenal--TALKING with a patient and asking intelligent questions. It needs no special training or instruments. And insurance underwriters love it.

From the Wikipedia article:

"Most private health insurance providers will use a particular high BMI as a cut-off point in order to raise insurance rates for or deny insurance to higher-risk patients, thereby reducing the cost of insurance coverage to all other subscribers in a 'normal' BMI range."

However, it's loaded with shortcomings. BMI does not take the following things into account: frame size, bone structure, masculinity, fat, cartilege, water weight, and even more. Plus its standards slide around depending on the country. You could be merely overweight in the US but Obese Level II in Japan. On top of that, the BMI scale slides up and down even more for professional athletes, the elderly, and children with adjustments made all over the place, rather like Papal Indulgences ("Well, you're technically overweight according to the BMI chart, but you're Asian, so that'll earn you a few extra points downward...and you're female and elderly...so let's add that into the calculation...")

So...what you have in a sliding scale that's whimsically dependent on situation, age, race, and insurance underwriters which is in itself a hit-and-miss methodology, the statistical equivalent ofthrowing a dart at a revolving dartboard whilst blindfolded, predicting where it will strike, recording the results, and calling it science. In fact, "Mathematician Keith Devlin and a restaurant industry association The Center for Consumer Freedom argue that the error in the BMI is significant and so pervasive that it is not generally useful in evaluation of health" (from "Do You Believe in Fairies, Unicorns, or the BMI?". Mathematical Association of America. 2009-05-01. http://www.maa.org/devlin/devlin_05_09.html. Retrieved 2009-05-22 and "Is obesity such a big, fat threat?". Cox News Service. 2004-08-30. Archived from the original on 2007-08-04. http://web.archive.org/web/20070804113535/http://www.rockymounttelegram.com/featr/content/shared/health/stories/BMI_INDEX_0830_COX.html. Retrieved 2007-07-08).

THIS is what less enlightened doctors are using these days to determine your span on this earth and whether or not you are worth treating or saving. Or hiring.

Once more from the Wiki article, then I'll leave it alone because I think you take my point:

In an analysis of 40 studies involving 250,000 people, patients with coronary artery disease with "normal" BMIs were at higher risk of death from cardiovascular disease than people whose BMIs put them in the "overweight" range (BMI 25–29.9).[22] (emphasis mine). In the "overweight", or intermediate, range of BMI (25–29.9), the study found that BMI failed to discriminate between bodyfat percentage and lean mass. The study concluded that "the accuracy of BMI in diagnosing obesity is limited, particularly for individuals in the intermediate BMI ranges, in men and in the elderly. ... These results may help to explain the unexpected better survival in overweight/mild obese patients.
(once again, my emphasis).


This, my friends, is the shaky framework on which the esteemed Herr Finkelstein has based his entire well-funded study and its conclusions. I call shenanigans. You begin to see why I've posted this under WTF Fridays. Bad science is still bad science even when it's got a lot of funding and a well-respected name behind it.



(Is this a good time to bring up that Duke University also has a highly esteemed and highly profitable obesity treatment clinic whose numbers will no doubt increase now that this study has been made public? No? Okay, I'll wait till later. Forget I said anything, but I'd be willing to bet that the funding for this little bit of Obesity Epidemic Flame Fanning came straight from the Obesity Clinic itself).

From the Finkelstein article:

With a burgeoning obese population in the U.S., the study has important implications for employers, as they are faced with increasing costs to insure full-time workers.

“Our study provides evidence of yet another cost of obesity,” said Finkelstein. “Employers should consider both the medical and productivity costs of obesity when thinking about investments in weight management or other wellness programs.”


Perhaps Finkelstein should familiarise himself with the CDC's redaction of the "400,000 people a year die from obesity!!" statement with a more revised and scientifically solid "less than 26,000 deaths per year can be blamed on obesity". You know what kills more people per year than being fat? TOBACCO. That's right, ladies and germs, smoking fags kills far more people faster and more effectively than the extra girth around your gut.

In fact, according to the CDC's website, the top ten killers of Americans are...

* Heart disease: 616,067
* Cancer: 562,875
* Stroke (cerebrovascular diseases): 135,952
* Chronic lower respiratory diseases: 127,924
* Accidents (unintentional injuries): 123,706
* Alzheimer's disease: 74,632
* Diabetes: 71,382
* Influenza and Pneumonia: 52,717
* Nephritis, nephrotic syndrome, and nephrosis: 46,448
* Septicemia: 34,828

"But but but!" I can hear Finkelstein's supporters bleating. "Aren't those things caused by obesity? Doesn't it raise the risk factors of those killers?"

*Sorry, I had to pick myself up from the floor, I was laughing so hard*

And I'm glad you piped up with the term RISK FACTOR. Remember, folks, these are statistical possibilities, not science, big Maybes, not fact. The fact remains that you cannot crawl inside someone's bloodstream and DNA at a glance and determine inconclusively whether or not there's a genetic pre-disposition for things like stroke and cancer. If you dad had colon cancer, yep, you PROBABLY have an increased risk for it. If your mom died of a stroke, yeah, MAYBE your odds are increased. But maybe they aren't. Any scientist worth his salt will tell you environmental factors are just as relevant in determining risk factors.

So if you eat crap, don't exercise, and pretty much live the sweet blob life, you most certainly will not be healthy (erm...duuuuuh) and will probably develop health problems. But if you are genetically destined to be heavy, like I am, you actually increase your risk of developing problems if you try to force your body to drop below its threshold weight. And in fact, folks who routinely weight cycle (shed and regain 20-40 pounds regularly) or folks who lose 20% of their body mass are actually at a greater risk of developing all the Horrible Things that are supposed to happen to you if you are obese (and oh yes, there's science, not theory, to back that one up).

And can someone tell me please how the things listed up there BEFORE obesity can be blamed on being a fatty? Chronic lower respiratory disease, unintentional accidents, and Alzheimer's disease, all stemming from obesity? I'm supposed to believe that?

Now take a look at how prospective employers would interpret this information. Two people, equally qualified, apply for a job. One of them is fat, the other is a smoker. Given a choice between these two, whom do you think the employer will choose? (Consider carefully: at a glance, it's not possible to tell if someone's a smoker, but it IS possible to tell someone's obese. Oh, and remember a lot of work places will give smokers two fag breaks a day plus 20 minutes every 6 hours to do with what people wish).

Perhaps that's taking it a step too far, but a study backed by the highly esteemed Duke University packs more of a punch for an employer who's really struggling to make ends meet insurance-wise. If one were adopt that mentality based on Finkelstein's findings without really thinking about it through, denying an obese person a job based solely on what health problems they might develop is the same discriminatory thinking that employers used to apply toward not hiring women because they might get pregnant and demand that blasted maternity leave.

If an obese person has diabetes, it might've been the result of his weight. But it might not be. Look at the risk factors for diabetes on any website. The top three (depending on type) are heredity factors, diet, and age. THEN obesity. And in some cases, if your mom had gestational diabetes when she was pregnant with you, that's an increased risk too (and for the record, GD hits randomly, think and thick alike).

Correlation is not causation, Mr Finkelstein, something a scientist of your learning should know by heart and adopt as his mantra. Publishing a study as flawed as this one and signing Duke's name to it is a discredit, and I'm willing to wager that in a few years, this study will be overturned just like the past studies that swore up and down that low-fat dieting was the way to go to lose weight. Or any of the ones that say dieting works (when 90% of people who diet gain back all their weight and then some) and thin is the same thing as healthy (ask an anorexic if they believe that one).

Shame on you, Mr Finkelstein. Bad researcher. Go to your mat now and stay there and think about what you've done.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Madhouse Wednesday: Sorry

Having lived for 9 of the best years of life in the illogical, fecund, and wholly welcoming United Kingdom, I learned that "Sorry" was a regular part of any conversation, from a discussion about topsoil erosion to anything political.

Watch any show on BBC, and you'll see what I mean. Barring that, take my word for it: sorry is a mainstay in any exchange.

"And you're in room 16, top of the stairs on the left."

"Sorry, which room?"

"Room 16...top the stairs on the le--no, sorry, on the right. Sorry, apparently I've put in someone else's teeth today."


Imagine that in a British accent, and you'll see why I found the Brits so endlessly entertaining. They have an incredibly self-effacing attitude that translates into every aspect of their being and, at its most extreme, turns into rabid and often pointless self-denial. It could be a hang over from WII where dearth first became an unwanted way of life, then equated to a moral aspiration, as a lot of things born of necessity usually wind up.

Don'tmention

Or maybe the Brits just have a huge guilt complex. Whichever it is, you can hear "Sorry" being used in the place of "Excuse me" or "Pardon".

Sorry, can I just squeeze through here? Thanks.

Sorry, could you just repeat that, please?

Sorry...can you pass me the salt if you've finished with it?

Sorry, it'll only take a mo to call that up on the computer.

Sorry to bother you, but the fish tank in your waiting room seems to have sprung a leak, and all the fish are flopping and gasping on the pebbles at the bottom most dreadfully. I tried to stopper the hole with a copy of today's Mail, but I guess it's a bit thin on news today, so could I just borrow a few rolls of tape and maybe some BlueTack, and with luck I can get it sorted for you? Ta."



I have to say, it was very calming to be among the Brits for so long--they don't seem to have the invented drama that so many Americans do, and their "Oh, just get ON with it" attitude is contagious. It speaks of a more responsible outlook on life as well, the sort of "Well, it's your own fault for attempting to do something so daft in the first place" attitude that lends itself to a self-moderating society. That is probably one of the most conclusive reasons why we've stayed overseas by choice for so long. Civility is worth everything to me these days.

The worry is that with "Sorry" being used so much, it loses its meaning and becomes more of a willing abasement than genuine penitence. Perhaps I'm weighing the word and its meaning too heavily, but when you consider that as a child, being forced to say "I'm sorry" was one of the most demoralising experiences ever (especially when you KNEW you were in the right), a new idea emerges: "Sorry" can have two meanings, one as a genuine statement of regret ("Wow, I am really sorry that I just stepped on your shopping bag full of eggs, ricotta cheese, and squid"), and the other as a way to get attention and regain a bit of order ("Sorry, I just need a bit of quiet so we can end this meeting on time so we can all go home and make life-altering love to our wives").

Whatever it means to the Brits, it seems to keep them going through the day. I rather like the notion of considering one's surroundings and how one fits into the fabric of a society rather than the American need to feel special, treasured, and of great worth.

And I like how "Sorry" can get you out of a lot of trouble. I remember an old Monty Python sketch where Eric Idle plays a man on trial, tried with about 20 things, each more heinous than the last, and at the end the Chancellor asks him, "Do you have anything to say for yourself?"

"Yes sir," replies Eric Idle with a sage nod. "I'm very, very sorry."

There's a pause, then the Chancellor asks, "Y--you're what?"

"I'm sorry," says Mr Idle. "I mean, look at the things I've done...it's terrible! What was I thinking? All those people!"

It takes the court so off-guard that they quickly adopt a whole, "Well, it was just one of those things, old boy...hey, it could happen to anyone, really..." and soon, they're serenading him with "For He's a Jolly Good Fellow...".

Maybe the Brits are more forgiving after all.

Friday, February 4, 2011

WTF Fridays: James Jordan

Come with me down memory lane for a moment, folks, back about 18 years or so...

In 1993, a body was discovered bobbing about in a little creek in the town of Bennettsville, SC, a state where they have two mottos: "While I breathe, I hope" and "Gawdamn, Jethro, that's your sister!" As it was 100 degrees out and the body had been rapidly decomposing for some time, coroner Tom Brown opted to cremate it, because being Bennettsville man, he had no facilities for handling a corpse of this or any sort.

There was no ID on the body. The only thing they could tell was that it was a black man in his 50s who had appeared to have been shot in the chest at point-blank range (the bullet was lodged in the aorta).

By cremating the victim, the coroner had removed any chance of dental or finger print identification. Even though the victim's car was later found right over the border in North Carolina (where they are slightly ahead of the learning curve with regard to coroners), he was treated in South Carolina as a murder victim because by gum, that's where he was found.

Here's the kicker: in South Carolina, where a professed belief in evolution will result in you becoming the town pariah, the position of coroner is elected...which means that anyone can run. That's right, the metalhead fuckwit in your high school history class who used sneak smokes between classes and said crude things about your mother's sexual predilections could be granted a crucial role in any murder investigation. No medical degree, not even the knowledge of which organ does what or even the ability to identify if one's been removed required. In fact, the previous coroner in that part of South Carolina, who had served for about 40 years, was legally blind.

Since this murder occurred, however, South Carolina has decided to hop onto the crazy whirligig of enlightenment and instill more rigid standards in who came become coroner. They decided that the candidates MUST have a high school degree, by gosh, and they won't settle for anything less.

In the case of this body being pulled from the creek in South Carolina, the coroner's defense was, "No one had been reported missing in North or South Carolina."

Flawless logic there, Tom old boy. No one had been reported as missing that you knew of...so by that logic, the man you'd just pulled from the river was accounted for ("Oh, yeah...we know exactly where he is. He's not missing. He's floating in a swamp").

But wait, there's more.

When the body was identified, guess who it was?

James Jordon, Michael Jordon's father. Yep. Of Chicago Bulls fame.

Larry Demery and Daniel Green (or Lord D.A.A.S. U'Allah, as he's now known), convicted in the murder, are still in jail. In true "It wasn't me, it was HIM" fashion, they're still blaming each other, even though the original jury was shown a video of Green dancing, wearing the two NBA rings and a watch that belonged to James Jordon.

This little news tidbit slid under the radar because Jordon's family asked the media to treat the matter with respect and leave them to their grief...which they did. The only reason it popped up again in 2010 was because the state bureau of investigations found that "laboratory technicians mishandled or omitted evidence" in the Jordan case 13 years later.

Ya think? I'd call cremating the body of a dead man just because you don't have a big enough fridge more than just a snafu in paperwork.

After cooling their heels for 18 years in the pokey, these two murderers are up for parole in a few years and are professing they're changed men. According to their own testimony, they were on their way to a robbery when they saw James Jordan napping at a rest area in North Carolina in his $40,000 Lexus and thought it would be much easier just to rob and shoot the man than go through all the hassle and folderol of a robbery.

This one still has me scratching my head and wondering why the legal system is bending over backwards to a) defend these guilty men, and b) feed, clothe, and shelter them on taxpayer money so they can continue to build up fraudulent law suits, take college classes, and generally have a much better quality of life than they had before they were arrested, and c) not put them down like the rabid dogs they are so they can't harm anyone else or, worse, breed.

In fact, as he was found guilty and led away in shackles after the original trial, Green remarked to the court at large, "This is Robeson County. What do you expect in this county?"

God forbid we should put a guilty man or men in jail as punishment for their crimes. What dark pit yawns before us, if we adopt that sort of dangerous thinking?

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Madhouse Wednesday: Keeping Secrets

Hello, and welcome to Madhouse Wednesdays. Please, take a seat...the show will begin momentarily.

Photobucket

What is Madhouse Wednesdays? Well, it's the brainchild of my internet buddy Kate who has had one of the worst years of her life--and probably one of the worst years of almost anyone you know--and as part of her healing, she blogs because I suspect that like me, if she doesn't write, her words get completely logjammed in her brain and only add to the strain of an already painful existence.

Kate picks a topic, and those of us involved in Madhouse Wednesdays write about it, however we interpret it. It can be short and whimsical, or it can be long and thought-provoking. If you'd like to know more about it, click here.

And if you'd like to participate, shoot her an email...I'm sure she'd make room at her table and offer you a basket of rolls before the dinner starts.

So, today's topic: Keeping Secrets

Nymph, in thy orisons be all my sins remembered...

secrets

I am a very good secret keeper. If someone says, "This is a secret...PLEASE don't tell..." I won't. Because I've had my confidence broken far too many times in people. That's how I know how sacred a secret trust is. The trouble is, I'll keep secrets, but I won't share any of my own.

My husband knows far too many of my own secrets, however. He's the only one who knows how hard I grieved when I lost Christopher. He knows how many nights I don't sleep, sitting up in bed and hunched over, unable to breath for the panic that grips me out of the blue and crying so hard I choke. He knows where my Ativan bottle is. He knows how closely my emotions run to the surface and how they explode without warning. And he knows nearly all of my regrets and guilt.

I hope that one day, Bea and Max will trust me with their secrets. Troubles always seem so big when you're a little kid. I hope they will understand that secrets shared are pains halved.

Remember Secret Clubs from childhood? You'd form around a common purpose, righteous in your unity...you'd develop elaborate handshakes, have clandestine meetings at recess, gaze scornfully upon anyone who came near... Usually it was based on a mutual dislike of someone who obviously deserved it. You'd shun them on the playground and at lunch, snickering cruelly when they approached you, laughing at everything they did behind your hand, knowing they were so pathetic they didn't deserve to breathe the same AIR as you.

And the irony is, given a few weeks, that club would collapse from disinterest, and someone would form a club about YOU.

Photobucket

My best friend Diane and I started a secret club called the Jane Hate Club (I won't use the girl's real name here because she's FB friends with some of my FB friends...yeep). Diane took our school photos and used them to make IDs with JANE HATE CLUB written on it. We carried these IDs around with us, knowing we were united in our dislike of this little wretch.

To be fair, Jane deserved it: she was incredibly cruel and liked nothing better than to try to turn friends against each other. She changed best friends every week, always started rumours, even wrote hateful things about you on the bathroom wall just to start shit. I had tried to be friends with her when she first moved to our neighbourhood from the deep south, but after 6 months or so I stopped trying when every friendly overture was returned with something uncivilised.

If I remember correctly, her father liked to draw cartoons of people having sex, and the one time I hung out at her house, she and I cut up her Underoos and made pillows out of them which pissed her mother off something fierce. Plus her dad was thoroughly livid when he came in and found us examining his naughty pictures. It was a very interesting day.

So Diane and I had weekly meetings of the Jane Hate Club, talking about the stupid things she said and did (she wasn't that bright, actually), the horrible outfits she wore, how she had the face of a cow, that sort of thing. Eventually Jane moved away, as did Diane, and life began anew, but for a while, I belonged to a secret club that made me feel Important. And I liked the feel of it, as you do when you're a kid and sometimes filled with very strong emotions you don't know how to handle.

My brother and sister always had secret clubs which I was never allowed to be in on, even if they were meeting at my own house. The thing about a secret club is that even if you're in one, everyone else's seems WAAAAY cooler. They're up to stuff that's much more fun, they may even have similar t-shirts, or maybe someone's parents takes them out to eat TOGETHER. Now that's bonding. And who knows what amazing secrets they were sharing at those Friday night sleepovers or what fantastically fun things they got to do together THAT YOU AREN'T A PART OF BECAUSE YOU ARE SIMPLY NOT GOOD ENOUGH? Whatever it is, you're not doing it, and there's another secret.

The older you get, the more intense the secrets, and then those same confidences cross the line in Rumorville. My sister was nearly devastated when one of her long-time friends started a rumor that Sis was pregnant, just to get a reaction and, more sickeningly, to gain attention for herself. There are energy vampires out there who just long for nothing more than drama and scandal, and finding none, they create some from thin air, Unfortunately, my sister happen to associate with one of the worst ones I've ever known.

Right now my head is empty of anyone else's secrets because I'm all grown up and I don't go for the notion any more. If someone says to me these days, "Can you keep a secret??" and I can tell it's something pretty tetchy, I'll just say, "No. I blab everything. I'm horrible at stuff like that. Don't say another word...LALALALLAAAAA..."

It's not worth it to me. I have my own secrets to safeguard...and I remember one of the first bon mots I've ever heard: three may keep a secret if two of them are dead.

Friday, January 28, 2011

WTF Friday: Men (Caution: Sweeping Generalisations Ahead)

In going along with an attempt to revive this blog and get my writing mojo going once more, I'm cottoning on to Poops' idea of WTF Fridays and trying to spew something out every Friday.

I'll also be participating in Madhouse Wednesdays (via Kate's blog) where the topic is pre-chosen (phew, less pressure there). Stay tuned.

My beloved Poops and I spend many an internet hour discussing all the things wrong with the world, specifically, what's wrong with women. I wouldn't classify either of us as feminists because I'm not sure what that title means any more.

Poops has an eager student in me. She has a straight-arrow way of seeing to the core of things and is unafraid to let fly some wisdom when it's necessary. And she's dealt with industrial truckloads of my Crazy calmly and sanely. Or maybe not--she could be emptying bottle after bottle of vodka as she types her sage advice and truthfully, I don't care because when we get to talking about our New World Order (she'll be Supreme Ruler, I'll be second-in-command because of my tendency to get distracted easily), we swear by Zeus' left nut that one of the first things we'll do is teach women how to be women, a lesson somehow overlooked in the rearing of females these days.

Which brings me to my first topic choice of WTF Fridays: Men.

Don't throw things at me. It may not be what you think.

I love men. I really do. My best mates in Uni were three guys that lived down the hall from me. We talked about everything, looked at porn, belched a lot, and one of them was very good at picking out clothes for me to wear to teaching interviews. I had girl friends too, but my always-there-for-you, hey-let's-watch-a-movie friends were guys.

Men are straightforward in their needs. When they're hungry, they say, "Hey, I'm hungry...think I'll get something to eat." They don't do what so many women do and try to justify or negate their hunger: "I can't possibly be hungry...I had breakfast not two hours ago" or "Well, I did only have piece of toast for brekkie...maybe a can of diet Coke will kick the hunger back a bit..."

Neither do men deny what they're really craving. How many women have had this internal monologue: "I really want a piece of cheesecake, but that's not good for me because it'll make me fat, so I'll have this celery stalk instead, and it will be just as good. Really. I'm not resentful at all." If a guy wants a pizza, he gets one, eats it, and has no regrets. He doesn't undermine his enjoyment of it by thinking he doesn't deserve it (he'll find a reason to). If a guy wants a beer, he gets one, drinks it, enjoys it, and is sated. He doesn't order a spritzer or a mineral water and feel deprived and falsely virtuous as he sips it, then sucks on the pulpy bits of lemon at the bottom, pretending they aren't sour.

A man's relationship with food is nowhere near as adversarial as a woman's is. Food is something a guy eats because his body needs fuel to go do more stuff. It's not a power struggle, and it satisfies a most basic urge.

Along those basic urge lines, if a guy needs to take a whiz, he does it wherever he wants, as loudly as he needs to, either in a toilet or against a tree. He doesn't wiggle his willie around and crouch closer to the bowl so it doesn't make that power splash in loo. He doesn't carry around "Masculine Wipes" so he's fresh as a daisy when his business is done. He wouldn't hold his wee in until he could find a private toilet so no one would hear him pee. And in going with a theme, if a guy needed to have a poo, he'd do it, then and there, no holding in because the smell might be offensive. Guys KNOW poops stinks (most of them, anyway...I once dated a guy who swore his didn't). It's one of those lessons they learn early on, and they're pretty zen about it. Open a window, light a match, spray the spray, move on, thanks

Guys go to the bathroom. Women excuse themselves.

Want to review what the definition of "excuse" is? In the verb form, it's "to make an apology for".

Did we do something wrong by obeying a natural body function?

It's a mindset we gals are taught from way too early an age. Be small, be dainty, be polite, smell of flowers, strive to be called pretty before you're called intelligent, and as my beloved Poops puts it so eloquently, be chaste and wonderful in public yet a raging sex bitch in the bedroom because that's how your please your man. And above all, apologise for everything because as a nurturer, if someone has come to harm or falls ill, it's YOUR fault for not protecting them enough from the world. In short, if you're not beautiful on all counts, you owe everyone whose eye falls on you an apology, and you can redeem yourself by dieting, changing your physical appearance, and hoping some man will marry you (remember how many of us played Bride as girls? Think guys ever played Groom as little boys??).

Something is very wrong in this thinking. It's wrong to have those impossible standards, but it's even more wrong to use them as a base in forming one's personality or how one shapes one's opinion of the world. In other words, it's your own fault if you buy into it because unlike countless generations before us, we women have a choice of how we live our lives, how we make money, when and where and with whom to have sex and children (if we do at all), and what direction we want our lives to go. We can control nearly every aspect of our mental well-being because we have choices. But somehow, for all our education and advancement, we still allow the opinions of others with regards to beauty and attractiveness guide our own opinions of ourselves.

Consider how many plastic surgeons out there are eager and willing to a) give you smaller or bigger boobs; b) tuck your post-birth tummy; c) suck the fat out of your thighs and shoot it into your forehead or chin; or d) plump up your lips so you look like you've got two pink inner tubes surrounding your teeth. We curl our straight hair and flatten our kinky locks with heat, money, time, and chemicals. We pluck our eyebrows then draw them back in with a pencil so they look more expressive. We spent millions of pounds/Euros/dollars per year on products to give us whiter teeth, smoother/clearer/more tanned skin, smaller waists, manicured nails, different hair colours, and longer lashes. Sharpened metal blades remove leg and armpit hair, and if that doesn't seem adequate, we have hair ripped from the roots by hot wax at great pain and at great cost. And what nature and makeup can't produce, we can always have done through surgery.

The amount of chemicals in any woman's bathroom cabinet is staggering, but more shocking is the amount of pain we inflict upon ourselves, both physically and mentally attempting to live up to some ideal image we have established as a collective.

Guys don't do this. If a magazine ad said, BIG BALLS ARE IN, you'd never see a guy running to a surgeon's demanding a testicular implant. Yeah, man breasts are pretty gross, but a guy's more likely to just learn to live with it or start lifting weights than go under the knife. Guys pat their big guts happily as if they're proud to have something they grew all on their own. They don't care if their asses sag or hair sprouts from their ears. The two things that really seem to bug men are not being able to get it up when they want to and going bald (and your beloved blogger here is one of those who finds an older, balding man with a bit of a paunch but a wonderful attitude very, very attractive). Those are their two main worries when it comes to appearance. That's it.

Flip open a magazine, and you'll see women portrayed as what I like to call "thin, brown, hairless, and descented": most of the models are rails, brown skinned, shaven/waxed/plucked, and most likely have no odor whatsoever because their armpit sweat glands have been pumped with botox so they won't leak through those $3000 Dior outfits they're modeling. Oh, and don't forget that models are, in essence, show horses, living dolls that simply wear the clothes and have no say in how they stand or what they look like. And that every picture has been run through a computer and every conceivable imperfection has been deleted. AND your typical model eats a regimented, incredibly repetitious diet determined by someone else,else and that every part of her body, from hair to toes, is addressed in a contract, so she is not free to cut her hair or dye it, get a tattoo or a piercing, or make any change in her personal appearance unless someone else says it's okay. Talk about confinement.

The women in those magazines represent about 5% of the human race, maybe less, and even they've been touched up by computers. THEY DON'T EXIST. Look around at the people you hang out with or what you see when you're at the grocery or on the bus. THAT'S what women look like.

Now look at the male models in those same magazines. Messy, touseled hair, usually a day or two of stubble in the chin, hairy legs, sometimes even smudged with dirt. They may be of a kind with their chiseled chests and faces, but they're a bit more real than the females. How'd they hang on to their little bit of reality?

Nobody tells a guy how he should look, even in the modeling world (if a male model doesn't suit a client's need, his first thought is not, Oh no, they don't LIKE me...I'm worthless!). Either that or they just don't buy into that message the way we women do. Somehow our self-worth and societal value (and what sorts of mothers and wives we are) got lock-stepped with our physical appearance. And ladies, that's just stupid.

It might have been a man (or a group of men) who came up with the notion of what made a beautiful woman, but it's we ladies who've bought it and continue to swallow it whole. To quote Sarah Jane Gilman, the last man who had an idea of what the most perfect human should look like had a tiny little mustache and shouted racist slogans as his followers goose-stepped around and killed innocent people.

Men are not at odds with their physical appearance the way we women are. They don't buy a pair of jeans that are too small with a the caveat that they'll diet into them. They wouldn't buy underwear than made their asses smaller or more "bootylicious". They don't carry 15 different lipsticks and a compact around with them for "quick touch ups". They are shockingly simple creatures with shockingly simple needs, and a lot of times they're dead correct when they say that women are crazy.

No, I'm not saying we women need act like men (unless you really want to). We just need to lighten up--on each each other and on ourselves because thin, heavy, or in between, this is all we get, ladies. Treat it with respect, fix what you can fix, and learn to look into the mirror with a bit of love and amazement that your heart pounds within your chest with no conscious thought on your part, your blood courses through your body all on its own, and your brain can still sort through the millions of images it sees daily and not implode.

That's where true beauty lies, ladies.

Friday, December 17, 2010

More Tom Foolery from ABC School for Rich Gits

Yesterday I went to Max's school to see a play called "Feelings", a culmination of a unit called How We Express Ourselves. The projects and home work that have been sent home over the last two months have been interesting, and the teacher in me really appreciates the use of cross-curriculum subjects they incorporated. There is a lot about that school I don't like, but the teaching is very effective and thoughtful, and Max particularly enjoys the art and music classes.

I got to the school one hour early because I know how fast the Juniour School auditorium fills up. Actually, it's not really an auditorium: the class rooms for grades 1 and 2 are built around an open circular area, and that area is referred to as the auditorium. It's big enough so that they can have indoor recess if they need to, stage plays, dances, parties, concerts, anything. It's unusual, but it works. Downstairs off the main hall is a huge area where they have kid-sized lockers and individual trays for the kids to put their shoes on in the morning, as each kid has to change into his "Hausschue" when he enters. When you look it, you see the rows of shoes or boots lined up on top of the little mini lockers, and it's really kind of cute. The Hausschue, btw, are usually carpet slippers (or in most cases now, Crocs, that the kids wear during the school day. They change back into their outdoor shoes for recess and going home.

Living so long in Europe, we've gotten to the point where we don't even blink an eye about going into someone's house and taking off our shoes. In the end, it kinda makes sense.

At any rate, I was there an hour early, as was a British lady I've seen off and on who's very friendly, along with a third mum whose oldest son is in Max's class and whose twin boys started at ABC school this year. For a woman with three boys very close in age, she's remarkably easy-going and sane, and as she's from Oz, I usually pick her brain about her homeland which is what I do when I encounter someone from another country who's willing to answer my questions.

The risers were set up, and I knew the entire 2nd grade was going to sing, "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" because Max has had to practice it this week. If you cringed when you read that, I don't blame you...it's what I did when I found out that's the song the music teacher chose. I guess it's better than the obvious, "Feelings" (oh whoa whoa FEEEEEEEEEEElings...).

So there I was with a heavy cold, having forsaken lunch and a nap because I really wanted to see this play, being as how I rarely get to attend Max's school things because of having Bea and that we live so far away. I was dizzy, jammed up, tired, but game...and dressed up because ABC school is where rich Bavarians send their kids. A lot of the students come from millionaire's homes, there's a prince or two in the ranks, and a lot of professional German footballers send their kids there. It's expensive as hell, exclusive, and pretty much up its own arse. The kids there are all about the labels, how many languages they can speak, what kind of car their daddies own...imagine Beverly Hills in Bavaria, and you'll get an idea of the sort of clientele that come there. So I dressed up a bit, wore my very sparkly (but very fake) huge diamond engagement band, my vintage wool coat with the fur trim, and did my hair. I normally don't give a shit what people think of me, but for Max's sake, I wanted to make a good impression. I even plucked my eyebrows.

As I'd gotten there so early, I got the front row, center aisle seat. This was to see Max, but it was also to hear better. I have a very slight hearing loss in one ear from about three decades of tinnitus and ear infections, but when I'm sick, my head's so bunged up I can barely hear. I sat crocheting a granny square, something I just learnt how to do, passing the time, and eventually, every seat was taken and there were close to 30 people standing in the back.

The kids had come in and were sitting according to t-shirt colour in the risers. Max's group was in red for "Furious", one group was in yellow for "Ecstatic"...you get the idea. Each group was broken down into smaller groups of 3-4 kids who had written their own plays for each emotion and were going to present them. It promised to be a very interesting and fun 90 minutes. I settled in and waited, grinning and waving at Maxman.

About 8 minutes before the program was due to start, the music teacher, the thinnest woman I have ever seen--seriously, some of the 2nd grades weighed more than she did--comes bounding up the center aisle with an older student in tow who was carrying a large video camera on a tripod. They splayed the legs out and plonked it down right between me and the other woman who'd gotten there at the same time, then started muttering to each other.

"There's not enough room," they were saying, looking worried. "There's not room for the camera." More looking around. "These people will have to move."

Uh oh, I thought.

The music teacher came over to me. "I'm sorry, but you'll have to move your seat," she chirped pleasantly. "There's not room for the camera."

"Uh huh," I replied, also pleasant. "Where were you planning on moving me?"

She looked around the packed room. "I'm not sure...wherever we can find a seat. The camera has to go HERE", and she pointed to the aisle between the two front rows, ignoring that it effectively blocked the first three seats of each row behind it.

"Well," I said, drawing myself up and staring at her, "I'm sitting here because I have trouble hearing. And I've been here an hour."

"But the camera has to go HERE," she repeated. "You understand, don't you?"

"And YOU understand that I'm here to see and listen to my kid, and that I'm not moving," I said, still smiling politely. "Don't you?"

Her face wrinkled like I'd just ripped a fart in her lap. "This is for the school DVD," she replied with a bit of a snarl. "There's no other place for the camera to go!"

"Then you should've thought of that BEFORE all the parents came," I replied evenly. "That's just poor planning. But here's an idea...why don't we push this row of chairs down the OTHER way? Then there'd be plenty of room." I pointed to the end of my row, where there was a good four feet of space between the last chair and the risers. "The children are small...there'd still be room for them to get by. And no one would have to move."

Her eyes went wide. "Oh NO! We can't do THAT!"

I shrugged and smiled. "Then I don't know what to tellya."

She frowned at me. "Don't take it PERSONALLY," she murmured.

"How else would you like me to take it?" I replied, folding my arms and taking a step toward her, more than ready to do battle.

By this point, the lady who was sitting across the aisle from me had come over, equally as pissed, and said, "You want me to MOVE?? We've been here and HOUR, and you NOW you're saying we need to move? Are you serious?"

"There's an empty seat next you, isn't there?" said the music teacher.

"That's for my husband...he's joining me from work."

"What about next to him? There's just a child sitting there. Can't they sit on someone's lap?"

"WHAT?" yelled an older grandmotherly type. "Are ye tellin' us to move? Look here, lassie..." and she stormed over. "We flew in from Scotland las' night and spent most of the night stuck in Edinburgh Airport because of the snoo. We BARELY made it here today. So nay, lassie, we're nae movin'! You figure somethin' else oot!"

"But the CAMERA--" warbled the music teacher, then choked to a stop, being now surrounded by the basilisk glare of several pissed off parents. She turned back to me, and I raised my eyebrows in a "I told you so" sort of way.

With an elaborate sigh, the music teacher managed to shift a few people around so I could sit in the front row (which earned me a few scathing looks because it meant splitting up some families, but as Poops reminded me when I related this story to her, they allowed themselves to be pushed around, and that's not my problem). I sat happily and waited for things to begin.

The skits were really funny. Max's group did an okay job (there were plenty better and plenty worse), and I could tell he REALLY loved being on the stage and had no fear of being front of a crowd at all, which came as a relief. It was well worth the time, and afterward we went into our class rooms for a lovely party. I had two very interesting conversations with a mum and a dad who are as disgusted by the elitism of the school as I am. They were both German which meant they were rich enough to send their kids to the school, just the sort of people I would've pegged as being snooty, but in fact they were very real and down to earth. I feel pretty sure we'll be in contact again before too long, and it was refreshing to hear Germans putting other Germans down and seeing the same problems I do. All in all, a good day.

And I didn't have to give up my seat. Score.

Saturday, December 11, 2010

Why I Will Never Participate In an Open Mic Poetry Night Ever Again

I woke up this morning thinking about this incident for no particular reason. It's one of those things that happens to you in life which never makes sense, but you figure, well, maybe when I'm older or more experienced or just more mellow I'll understand what went down...so you shelve it in the back of your brain to dwell upon later.

But it bubbled to the surface of my frequently overheated brain, and I thought I'd air it out here and see if maybe after all this time someone could shed some light on it. Here goes.

I started writing poetry in 9th grade. I don't know why, but my freshman year was an incredibly wonderful time for me. For one thing, I went to a high school out of my district, BHS, to play in the school orchestra (my "assigned" high school didn't have one). In my county, you see, I was bused an hour away to a middle school to even out its number of white kids even though there were several good schools 15 minutes away from me. In my middle school, I was a minority, and it would've continued onto High School, but I'd already been so beaten up, harassed, and generally made miserable for those two years that my parents pushed for and got a transfer to the HS 15 minutes up the road known to have a much better academic program. And an orchestra. I wanted to continue my studies of the violin and major in music in Uni, and I need to play. A lot.

I wasn't the only one desperate to get out of our county-designated school. Many, many families actually rented a house or an apartment or even just one room so they could be on the lease in the busing zone so they wouldn't have to go to LHS. Or they flat-out moved. Or just plain lied, setting up a PO box in the school district where they wanted to go. Yeah, LHS was THAT bad. My sister went there and was so traumatised by it that she begged my parents to send her to private, radical, fundamentalist Christian school just to get away from it all.

So I got a fresh start at BHS. VERY few people knew me, and though it was lonely at first, I saw it as an opportunity to start anew. I went by a different name, lost a lot of weight, dressed differently, dyed my hair, and generally let out all the creativity and intelligence I'd had to hold back in middle school for fear of getting mocked even more than I already was. I joined the drama club and the literary magazine, stopped being afraid to speak up in class, pretty much did what I wanted without caring what anyone else thought.

And I discovered that people were receptive to it. Teachers complimented my poems, my stories, my left-field ideas. Nobody knew who I was or where I'd come from, and that was wonderful. Within 4 months I had a circle of friends. By 5 months I had my first boyfriend. At 6 months I had another boyfriend, a senior, and a date to the senior prom. Life was finally falling into play.

And through all this, I wrote. I filled notebooks with ideas, songs, notions, sketches, truths, bon motts, everything. Some things I submitted to the literary magazine, some things I sent off for publication, some I just shared with a few friends. But it was all coming together, and I felt alive and wonderful and buoyed by my own intelligence and creativity.

I felt wholly confident, and for a fat girl, that wasn't too shabby.

So when I entered University, I saw it the same way in terms of starting over. High school started off on a high note but ended on a horribly sour one, and I needed a re-set. My poems had been published in a few small places, but I really wanted more affirmation.

So one night I noticed a sign for an Open Mic Poetry Reading--All Welcome! on the wall outside of the Performing Arts hall on my way to my violin lesson and thought, Well, why not? My violin teacher was married to the head of the English department, and she said I could absolutely bring some poems to read. She drove me up to the pub where it was being held after my lesson, bought me a ginger ale, and we sat and talked until it was time for the event to start.

Her husband, btw, is one of the best professors I ever encountered on my travels. I'm still in contact with him via email.

In order to participate, you had to sign your name on a list, write the number of poems you were going to read (no more than 3), your phone number (I don't know why), and where you were from. I did this all without complaint, and listened to several wonderful works read by students, professors, locals, and anyone who was brave enough to take the mic. Some were real stinkers, but who was I to judge? I was only 18 years old.

Finally I stood up to read my three poems. One was called "3 a.m.: A Reflection" and was a few lines about how everything seems possible in the wee small hours of the morning. I forget what the other one was, but the third told about a man who challenged God and lost, and as punishment, he was taken into Heaven when he didn't deserve to go and placed in a darkened cave with a single candle that grew brighter every day for eternity until he burned away, piece by piece. I thought it was an interesting notion, but it was a rather long poem (two pages of free verse), and I was glad when I was done reading it. Shortly after that, the event ended, and one of the other readers came up to me and said how much liked my stuff which made me very happy.

We all went home, and as I was preparing for bed around 10 am that night, the phone rang. I picked it up excitedly because no one ever called me.

"Is this Yorkie?" said a loud male voice.

"Yes, it is."

"Good. I was at the poetry reading tonight and heard what you read."

"Oh! Okay...?"

There was a pause, then the voice got really angry. "I just wanted to tell you that what you did was really out of line, and you shouldn't even have come, if that's what you were going to do."

I gasped, and my stomach turned cold. "What?? What'd I do?"

"It was a POETRY reading, you idiot. And you read PROSE. You obviously can't tell the difference."

My throat was completely dry, and I felt like crying. "Oookay. Erm...who is this? Can I have your name?"

"Ummm...I'd rather not give it."

"Okay. If you won't even give your name, then your opinion means nothing to me. I didn't read prose, it was poetry. And I'm hanging up now. Goodbye." *SLAM*

I sat on my bed and shook for about two hours until I fell asleep. I looked at my poems and wondered if maybe I'd confused free verse with prose, maybe I'd made a massive mistake in reading something, maybe he'd actually been right. The next day, I saw my violin teacher and tearfully told her about it. Even though we didn't really get along, she said, "That's ridiculous. You didn't read prose. It was free verse. Even my husband said it was. That guy's an idiot...just ignore him." Which I tried to do, but for about 4 months after that, I listened to every voice that passed me, trying to see if I could find who it was that had been so horrible. The voice on the phone had been very distinctive, and it was burned into my memory. I've always been good with that sort of thing.

It wasn't until Spring that I discovered the source. My University was pretty small, and the departments were rather tightly-knit. Once I dropped my music major and went into English Education, I discovered a new world of self-proclaimed geniuses and poets who insisted they were "undiscovered" and that the world just wasn't ready for them yet. And the rest of us sucked. You know the type, the "I'm soooo black in my soul. My poetry is black. My thoughts are black. Listen to the darkness I spill forth onto my parchment, behold my words. I AM THE EMBODIMENT OF ALL THAT IS ANGSTY AND DARK!" or as my friend Kelly quoted from one of her own poetry classes, "Inky black pools of inky black blackness".

There was a gentleman about three years ahead of me in the program who considered himself the most intelligent, most literary, most gifted writer to come through onto this mortal plane ever and spent most of his time holed up in his favourite proff's office [in his own mind] wittily discussing Joyce and Eliot and Pound. He was supremely arrogant, so superior in his thinking that he often argued with proffs as they taught their classes. And for some reason completely unbeknown to me, the fluffy, empty-headed girls just flocked to him like he was a font of literary blessings. He would quote a bit of Shelley or Keats to them, they'd turn red and giggle, and he'd sneer.

Yeah, I'm sure you've met one of these guys before. You just want to punch them in their scowling faces. And here's the thing: he was unbelievably ugly. I'm not just saying that because he was a major-league, profession dickhead. He genuinely was so homely that when I first saw him, I thought he'd been in a horrible disfiguring accident of some sort (he hadn't). He had downward-slanting piggy little eyes, a long upturned nose, large teeth so bucked that his heavy lips couldn't even close over them (so when he breathed, his mouth hung open), and absolutely no chin. On top of that he wore small, intellectual's glasses, a goatee, and rarely washed his hair. When he walked, his toes pointed inward, and he leaned forward like a lumbering beast with a stone in one hoof. He always wore a faded oxford shirt with khaki pants that were frayed along the hems because of his scruffling trudge and beat-up DockSiders.

There was nothing attractive about him whatsoever, and I'm certain he compensated by trying to appear overly intelligent. I happened to sit down to dinner with a class mate of mine where he was sitting snuffling up his food like an aardvark, and when he looked up and saw me, his eyes narrowed to the point of almost disappearing, and a scowl took over his entire face. I greeted him cheerily, having just come from a paid violin gig, and when he let a "hi" drop out of his mouth foaming with malevolence, I knew I KNEW in an instant he was the choad that had rung me months back and said those wretched things. And at the same moment, he knew *I* knew, and I decided to make his life miserable.

I smiled politely, asked him how he was.

"Fide," he said (his nose was nearly always clogged whenever I saw him and heard him speak).

"That's good. It's great weather, isn't it? So rare for this time of year."

Blank nod.

"I bet you miss winter, though. Are you into skiing? Are you one of those crazies who goes night skiing up in West Virginia? You look like you might..!"

"Nuh."

"Oh, I see you got the pork chops! I always find they're rather tough, but yours look wonderful and tender. That's lucky, isn't it? I think the food's gotten worse in the time I've been here. I don't know how they do it, quite honestly! I guess they just figure we cover everything with ketchup and don't really think about taste because maybe we're too drunk all the time, but I tell you...a good pork chop is quite a treasure. I don't eat too much pork myself because I rarely enjoy it, but I guess this time we got lucky--"

But by this point he'd already stood up, took his tray, and left the table, throwing a disgusted look over his shoulder at me. My friend sitting next to me said, "Wonder what that's all about?" and I said, "Guess some people just don't like conversation when they're inhaling their food."

I can guarantee I would recognise him immediately if I saw him on the street, if not for his ugliness, then for his arrogant demeanor. I can forgive a truly miserable person for acting like a fuckwich on a platter, but the result is that I have never again attended a poetry reading, an open mic night, a poetry slam, or anything of that ilk since. I realise it's been over 20 years, but I knew that if I were to attempt one again, I might run into his type, maybe worse, and quite frankly, my fragile ego couldn't handle it.

The only time I can see myself reading something at one of those events is when I've published my own stuff, and someone begs me to read a section from my own book. Then I call the shots and can give a hearty "piss off" to any jesters or sour dicks that happen to wander along and criticise the outpourings of my mind.

And that's power.